Not much point argueing with you as you obviously don't pay attention, and must not have been watching the world cup, or seen any of him in Spain, or watched him in EUFA, in particular vs Fulham in the final, hes a very different player, he is stronger, bigger and a better he got the golden boot in Spain two years in a row, and has a knack of being exactly in the right place at the same time, this season he managed 18 goals and 6 assists from 31 games, last season he scored 32 from 32 games and got 10 assists this is phenomenal, this world cup he has 2 goals and one assist from 4 games, being one of the form players of the tournament, 2 might not sound like many but last golden boot managed 6, because he failed at united doesn't mean he is a bad player, Berbatov was great for us at united obviously has been a giant flop, to be sucessfull at a club it is not only about being a good player, personally everything has to be right at your new home club and sometimes moves don't work which can be for many reasons, could be as simple as didn't get along with the manager, Forlan is a prime example of this, or don;t you think Harry is a very good judge of a player because he keeps banging on about how good Forlan is, lets just see what happens might not even get him.