This is a tough one if we look at what he would bring to the team and his ability which united cant get out of him as we did then its a clear cut yes, but there is more to it than that!
Has everyone forgoten how he disrespected the club, us fans and gave big MJ a huge headache causing so much disruption in the dressing room, the Berba saga had a large part in MJ's dismissal at THFC.
A genius he his, bags of ability and skill he has and would fit into our method of play.
Loyalties he doesnt not have (neither do most of todays overpaid pre-madonnas), respect for adoring fans means sweet FA and they way he openly sulks on the pitch and on the bench when things dont go his way is another big issue. He wasnt even prepared to leave honourably and really belittled everything about THFC.
So for me all that out weighs his playing ability, there are other players that would fit our style of play.
Berbatoss should never have the opportunity to pull our team colours on again, unless he buys a top from a sporst shop.