Alan Hutton

[bigv]

Both players have different qualities.
 
Personally i would play Corluka as i feel he is more solid in defensively, Charlie may offer less offensively but for me that isn't as much as a priority as been better when we haven't got the ball. I think Corluka is actually decent offensively, and he can give Lennon an option on the over lap which is good. But for me Hutton looks shakey when he's not got the ball, which is a little scary.

Finally a voice of reason!!!!

[Gareth Keown]

Chore Luka solid defensively is a myth... his frailties been camouflaged mightily by Lennon's unselfish covering of his wide fat behind, the last year or so...

Kaboul is actually the best RB we have defesively/offensively overall.... by a margin... but he's needed more at CB nowadays..

Hutton is actually improving with regular games, confidence-building and continuity.... far better than the Snail...